logoalt Hacker News

cacheyourdreams • today at 4:14 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Dictionaries don't define things they define words. Although I don't disagree that "a person" is a pretty poor dictionary definition. I'm not sure it's circular though since "a person" is defined as "a man, woman, or child" and would seem to exclude anybody's cHaTBoT.


Replies

xgulfie • today at 4:49 PM

It's fiction but, a Vulcan, a Hobbit, or a little green man from Mars would obviously be considered a person. Being a person doesn't necessarily mean literal human in theory

rdiddly • today at 4:21 PM

The circularity is from defining a human as a person, while a person is a human. It doesn't go away when they split it into categories (men, women and children) and in fact they've only incurred further problems now, by excluding the nonbinary crowd.