logoalt Hacker News

CJefferson • today at 4:37 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I mean, it's entirely possible, people do GeoIP all the time. How is it difficult? I mean they are now blocking France, which proves they can do French-specific things surely? Why technically is it different to reject some requests from France, vs rejecting all requests from France?


Replies

trashb • today at 5:54 PM

In the other post about Quad9 on the homepage right now (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50545958) this is explained, though in this article it is not as clear.

  > Quad9 has already tried this, in Germany. In the Sony Music v. Quad9 case, Quad9 used geoIP blocking for German users while the case continued. Sony's lawyers used a VPN to reach the content "from Germany" anyway, the court agreed this was non-compliance, and Quad9 was fined for contempt. 
  > As Quad9 told TorrentFreak: "There is no legally useful way for us to define a French user." 
That explains that the difficulty of GeoIP likely not being sufficient for the court as was tried in Germany. This is not a technical issue but an issue of what the court would find sufficient, and the need to identify a user as French. By saying they don't serve French altogether I think they are dodging the non-compliance on the current case.
➕ show 1 reply