logoalt Hacker News

egorfine • today at 4:42 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> DNS is the wrong place to do censorship,

You probably wanted to make a top comment with that, not reply to mine. I was quoting the original author.

> You can still type the IP and it will connect

No. Not in the modern internet, no.


Replies

trashb • today at 5:27 PM

  > not reply to mine
No, I am responding to that quote and your claim that their real desire is to "to censor the internet". I am saying that if that is indeed their desire DNS is still the wrong place to do that.

  > No. Not in the modern internet, no.
Can you elaborate? As far as I understand DNS is address lookup, so IP address retrieval. If you know the IP you can connect without DNS involved. Therefore not really censoring anything by censoring DNS responses.
➕ show 1 reply