Until Colt's revolver after 1830, few of those weapons were suitable for routine carry. When you were going off to fight, you got your weapon ready, which with flintlocks involved putting in fresh powder. Early pistols didn't stay safely ready for use. So pistols were offensive weapons.
Concealed carry, the early years: For loading a Philadelphia Deringer, one would typically fire a couple of percussion caps on the handgun, to dry out any residual moisture contained in the tube or at the base of the barrel, to prevent a subsequent misfire. One would then remove the remains of the last fired percussion cap and place the handgun on its half-cock notch, pour 15 to 25 grains (0.97 to 1.6 g) of black powder down the barrel, followed by ramming a patched lead ball down onto the powder, being very careful to leave no air gap between the patched ball and the powder, to prevent the handgun from exploding when used. ... A new percussion cap would then be placed on the tube (nipple), and the gun was then loaded and ready to fire.[1]
Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.
>Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.
If your goal is a legal basis gun control then "handguns sucked then" is a stupid argument because the obvious counter is "ok, well random dudes could just buy the kit that let them go toe to toe with professional infantry so why don't you give us that and we'll call it even" and that's probably way worse for whatever the next thing you want after you get your gun control is.
> Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.
People routinely carried and possessed other guns though so I'm not sure that's a good argument. At best you are arguing against concealed carry but there is no constitutional amendment addressing concealed carry.
If you want to argue that the 2nd Amendment only talks about what would mostly be considered a professional or semi-professional military then you have to revert back to 10th Amendment since the 2nd Amendment doesn't ban citizens from owning firearms it just grants the right to have a militia, ergo each state unless another constitutional amendment happens at the federal level can set forth (or not if they don't want to regulate it) the right for individual citizens to own firearms. The worst case is you get some states banning it, and other states having a lot more lax laws, something more akin to the roll back of Roe V Wade. Anti-gun rights activists should be careful that they don't disrupt the status quo less they find even fewer restrictions, as anti-abortion activists discovered when states began enshrining the right to an abortion in their own state constitutions.
It doesn't matter anyway because we as a society for good reasons decided that we wanted folks to be able to carry a handgun concealed or to otherwise own and carry firearms. That's all we really need - we just say we want to do something and then we get to do it.
> Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak.
So the 4th amendment that says this:
"... secure in their persons, houses, papers, ..."
doesn't concern digital information because the notion of information stored digitally and not in paper wasn't envisioned by the Constitution?
But at the same time the people who wrote the constitution knew full well repeating firearms were coming at some point and didn't think it made enough difference to change anything or note anything about it. They saw and were offered to buy such firearms both for personal and military use and had personally saw many other firearm improvements and reduction in costs throughout their life.