Bc the actual thing that we are enjoying and looking for in this work is not aesthetics as we have long believed but purely the sense of the presence of the creator. This stuff made by robotic calculations means nothing because it comes from nobody, so we learn nothing about being ourselves through the work of others from it. It has proven, at long last, that aesthetics mean nothing
Some people do. I'm one that doesn't. I honestly don't care who made a thing and I'd rather not know if it would interfere with my appreciation of it. So, I think nothing has been proven. People who are more interested in other people than in the things they create will always say aesthetics are meaningless and it's the artist that's important and vice versa for the rest of us.
Aesthetics is about ratios -- relations between things and aspects of things -- and, applied to humans, genetic fitness. It's the sort of thing an AI can easily hack. That they're still not great at it speaks to a lack of focus; it's just not their priority.
Back in the day, there was this discussion about music. Some people prefer going to live concerts, where it's easy to get "a sense of the presence of the creator." We believed that this was an appreciation for musicianship, as opposed to aesthetics. Others prefer listening to music at home. I'd maintain that this is a purely aesthetic appreciation. And the day AI can generate genuinely good music is very near at hand, I think...
Thing is, though... Man... That "Whitepill" song is really something. The aesthetics don't trouble me. The song, which is mediocre at best, is unimportant. What troubles me is that it's more brazen than Soviet propaganda from the 1970s in its message and delivery.
If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome," they really haven't been paying attention. Totally clueless.