logoalt Hacker News

sashank_1509 • today at 1:41 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

Why is it so different in maths compared to theoretical physics?


Replies

_mjk • today at 10:47 AM

Maths starts from axioms / existing proven work, and extends knowledge with newly proven facts.

Theoretical physics starts from (incomplete) observation and compatible theories plus targets an open question. There often are many solutions, but the real question is, which one holds up if the broader field is examined?

Consider what happened to the observation of the Higgs boson? There were numerous string theory flavors, all (more or less) consistent with current observations, but predicting different mass for the Higgs. Clear path for elimination of a lot of previously "correct" models.

In that empirical approach, making experiments and comparing to old/current/future work is a necessity to judge a models in a given regime. In fact, it is the differentiating factor in maths and theoretical physics.

hershkumar • today at 6:01 AM

Is it? I’m pretty sure most mathematicians working on research level math are similarly tucked into specializations. perhaps the only major difference is that in physics the language and jargon differs (and this is purely anecdotally) more across subfields.

yk • today at 2:18 AM

In physics if you have a important open problem, you can probably just throw numerics at it to compare theory with experiment. The mathematical insight on the other hand is there to illuminate what's going on in nature, which is a much more amorphous target than the lists of very concrete problems mathematicians have just lying around.

➕ show 2 replies
utopiah • today at 5:59 AM

Funny you asked that, I was literally going to comment on how closed it seemed with https://github.com/teorth/erdosproblems/wiki/Disclaimers-and...

I would also had that in math currently you can verify proofs, like Lean, which also means the tooling itself is a good match for automation, I don't know what's the situation in theoretical physics.