Describing the comments on this PR as "shitting all over the proposed fixes" seems wildly out of proportion? This is direct, productive feedback on a PR that led to a consensus and approval on an appropriate fix in ~a week, we don't need to make the OS process sound worse than it is.
To me it looked like entirely reasonable discussion. Return one value or return an other value. And which one should be chosen based on what is in general expected. And then also consider what parts of code can this sort of change impact.
I really find sad how far we have gone. Purely technical merits of a fix should always be an open conversation.