logoalt Hacker News

nine_k • today at 8:14 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

> sounds like a socialist scheme

Public libraries were invented in 1830s, and a few existed (notably Boston's), but the proliferation of tax-supported public libraries is entirely a capitalist scheme, implemented privately by Andrew Carnegie, a steelmaking magnate.


Replies

brookst • today at 3:19 PM

That’s not really how it works… something isn’t a capitalist policy because a capitalist person supported it.

Fire departments are 100% socialist. That does not change depending on who supports or opposes them.

Carnegie was an interesting character. Certainly a capitalist as a person, but his support of tax-funded libraries does not transform public libraries into capitalist institutions.

ninjalanternshk • today at 11:16 AM

The most capitalist thing about capitalism is that capitalists will do anti-capitalist things if it benefits them.