logoalt Hacker News

Carnival Cruises emits ten times more sulphur oxide than all of Europe's cars (2019)

477 points • by sammatilda • today at 9:13 AM • 298 comments • view on HN

Comments

tito • today at 11:33 AM

One unintended side effect of the removal of sulfur from shipping fuels is a drastic reduction in cloud cover over the ocean. This is estimated to have doubled global warming in the 2020s (!).

I’m exploring how to cleanly re-create those lost clouds over the ocean. Fuel additives, spraying sea salt into clouds, modifying ship routing. If this is up your alley hit reply.

➕ show 22 replies
nehal3m • today at 11:12 AM

One of the easiest wins would be outlawing burning bunker fuel for recreational purposes, would it not? I'm not posing this as absolute truth but I don't see any direct limitations to personal freedoms. Let cruise operators burn something less ridiculously dirty and if that prices cruising out of the market, so be it.

➕ show 8 replies
trashb • today at 4:01 PM

At this point I don't see why cruise ships are still allowed, I say ban them. They are super polluting, dangerous for spreading disease and many more problems (bad treatment of the staff, a role in human trafficking, tax evasion). They are completely optional, they exist purely for entertainment/excess.

If humanity agreed to stop all cruise ships we would safe more pollution then any other measure we are forced to make currently (which could still be done in addition). To me the fact that cruise ships are still operating proves that most governments are not interested in actually improving climate pollution.

To me it seems like the lowest hanging fruit in the climate disaster.

➕ show 6 replies
tptacek • today at 5:09 PM

Cruises are horrible and all, but is this a super meaningful comparison? Are cars a primary source of SOx pollution? This is a very specific comparison, which makes me wary.

throw0101c • today at 4:08 PM

As noted, this is from 2019. The International Maritime Organization put restrictions on the sulphur content in emissions starting 2020-01-01:

* https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/hottopics/pages/sulphur-2...

* https://www.cmacgm-group.com/en/low-sulphur-imo-2020-regulat...

Is this particular issue (sulphur) still an issue?

➕ show 1 reply
ben_w • today at 11:09 AM

Negatives: acid rain

Positives: seeds cloud formation in the right way to cool, mitigating some of the effects of the greenhouse gasses.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injectio...

➕ show 2 replies
dang • today at 12:40 PM

Discussed at the time:

Carnival Cruises emits ten times more sulphur oxide than all of Europe’s cars - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20203006 - June 2019 (158 comments)

everdrive • today at 12:55 PM

Carnival Cruises feel like they're up there with golf courses for some of the worst resource management practiced today. I can't think of anything worse than being trapped on a cruise ship.

➕ show 3 replies
sct202 • today at 1:51 PM

The cruise industry has started to move towards liquified natural gas powered ships which emit very little sulfur oxide just due to natural gas having almost no sulfur. Carnival has 11 LNG ships out of its fleet of 90 so there is some progress for this specific pollutant.

tpm • today at 11:22 AM

This article is from 2019, before the 2020' IMO limits came into power.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/15/oil-imo-2020-marks-the-bigge...

passwordoops • today at 11:39 AM

And what's changed in the 7 years since this was last posted?

➕ show 1 reply
timbit42 • today at 1:24 PM

Europe has a lot more hybrids and EVs now. It's probably more than ten times today.

kakacik • today at 10:56 AM

Same goes for all big ships with containers, and this is well known for 2+ decades. Big ships simply have engines designed to take the cheapest, shittiest fuel and somehow cca burn it to keep costs per km as low as possible.

➕ show 3 replies
BeFlatXIII • today at 3:26 PM

How do they compare to Royal Caribbean or Disney?

➕ show 1 reply
jeremyjh • today at 11:48 AM

Needs 2019 in the title.

jordemort • today at 12:44 PM

then sink them

coryfklein • today at 5:16 PM

Big news! When you burn dirty fuel you put pollutants in the air. Cars don't emit sulphur oxide because the fuel they burn is much more regulated.

Maybe it is a hit piece on Carnival? Because the entire cruise industry emits a whopping 0.8% of the sulphur dioxide that the shipping industry itself does [0].

[0] Fourth International Maritime Organization Greenhouse Gas Study 2020, page 11 figure 9, https://wwwcdn.imo.org/localresources/en/OurWork/Environment...

JensenTorp • today at 12:35 PM

This article was widely mocked for its false equivalence when it was published years ago. Surprised to see its corpse being dug-up on HackerNews.

Towaway69 • today at 4:08 PM

Just yesterday i had this idea for a far side comic where a cruise ship sails past a cow transport ship and the cows wave to the humans.

Perhaps we should also be thinking about non-human cruise ships or do they magically pollute less because they transport the worlds future burgers?

nsoam • today at 10:58 AM

It’s old and rich people who use these, so don’t worry, nothing will happen to them.

Cars used by the poor to get to their jobs, on the other hand…

➕ show 5 replies
nottorp • today at 11:36 AM

> Cruise giant - Carnival Corporation - emits 10 times more air pollution than all of Europe’s cars – study

Seriously? How much "other pollution" do "all of Europe's cars" emit, besides the sulphur oxide?

bethekidyouwant • today at 3:00 PM

Yes, a thing that does have sulfur (heavy fuel oil) emits more than a thing that doesn't have sulfur (gas) . even if one is not the same size as the other.

t1234s • today at 6:59 PM

Is this mostly from the smell of the disgusting people they allow on their ships?

guywithahat • today at 1:55 PM

*because cars don’t produce meaningful amounts of sulfur oxide

This wasn’t worth digging up from 6 years ago.

swolios • today at 4:29 PM

Wait till you see how bad cargo ships and oil tankers pollute. All these ships use bunker fuel.

dark-star • today at 7:59 PM

and yet, people in Europe still genuinely believe that by driving electric vehicles, they are saving the planet :-D

titzer • today at 2:36 PM

But it's run by billionaires, so we let them do it.

mcjenkisns • today at 1:54 PM

Now imagine ships shipping Chinese crap around the world

excannuk • today at 8:16 PM

[dead]

afh1 • today at 12:05 PM

And China burns more coal than the rest of the _world_ combined, but that doesn't get attention here because sanctions on China would make everything so expensive for Europeans that it would show they don't _really_ care about the environment.

➕ show 4 replies
bozdemir • today at 12:44 PM

Pollution, carbon footprint and global warming regulations are always pushed to working class people.

funkytownjoe • today at 1:56 PM

Now imagine all those Chinese cargo ships shipping cargo around the world.