logoalt Hacker News

jonathanlydall • today at 10:04 AM • 8 replies • view on HN

I was recently thinking of the depiction of AI in Star Trek. Specifically TNG, DS9 and VOY, and specifically their "Computer, ..." prompts, not the more advanced kinds like for Data or holograms (including the EMH).

I recall thinking at the time I first watched them that it was a bit weird that the computer seemed capable of answering general questions and doing things like data analysis, but that seemed to be all it was ever used to do.

And I think this is exactly the kind of AI we now have today, you can ask it a general question which it can somewhat mostly answer correctly, but requires human guidance to be applied effectively at real world problems.


Replies

fearthemachine • today at 5:29 PM

I've been watching quite a bit of Trek lately and the degree to which the ship's computer seems like an LLM is remarkable, even down to things like the ways they fail or go loopy when they operate too long, the ways they can "squeeze" into lower-resource environments but become "dumber" and crippled, the way they seem to need a big-ass library of data to work optimally, the way you can grant your particular job more computing resources and it'll be "smarter" (fires up a bigger model or more intermediary check-and-correct steps, maybe!) et c. They surely wrote it that way for the convenience of the script writers (need something to short-cut technical work, but that isn't so capable it just solves every problem before a plot can develop) and it did indeed always seem weird that it could be as capable as it was while not being way more capable than depicted... and yet! We built exactly that.

It's first and foremost a revolution in computer UI, as I see it. Or at least it will be as soon as I can afford the hardware to run the damn things on my computers...

francisofascii • today at 1:01 PM

Yep. There are several scenes in TNG where a crew member, Geordi comes to mind, is collaborating with the computer, having a back and forth brainstorming conversation, solving a problem. Very much like using an LLM today.

➕ show 1 reply
xg15 • today at 6:54 PM

Fully agreed. There were a number of episodes that dealt with gaps in abilities that seemed unrealistic and counterintuitive, but weirdly turn out correct now that we have LLMs.

I also liked how Star Trek (probably without planning to) created an entire spectrum of AIs with different abilities, starting with the Computer, to the semi-sentient Holodeck characters, to the EMH and Data as "for all intents and purposes sentient" and finally to the Borg as an entire AI species where no one thinks about sentience anymore.

Maybe we should use this scale to make different "levels" of AI more concrete instead of vague concepts like AGI and ASI.

FinnKuhn • today at 11:34 AM

I always imagined AI as what you saw in futuristic movies. There it was generally text or language based. We generally have that now.

What we don't really have is physical AI, e.g. autonomous robots, human looking robots, self-driving cars, etc. I think this is what is next.

➕ show 1 reply
teamonkey • today at 1:56 PM

The weird thing is that the Enterprise’s computer is a writing device to serve the story, and so its abilities from episode to episode vary wildly. This somehow makes its behaviour seem more consistent with modern LLMs.

The most unrealistic thing about it is that it would often openly reply “unknown” and then stop talking.

aeonik • today at 10:48 AM

I had the same thought.

When when I got my CS degree, I revisited this thought, and reinforced it.

I thought, this is not how AI and Statistics work. We would need to have an ensemble of thousands of specialized models to run a ship.

threethirtytwo • today at 10:41 AM

The ai we have today is even stranger than the star trek computer.

On one hand it is far superior to humans. On the other hand it needs our guidance. Both of these are true at the same time.

0xbadcafebee • today at 3:35 PM

Their computer isn't AI because AI is too unreliable to run a starship. So they use a conventional computer with lots of software and a big processor. It's just deterministic programs linked to a STT. Probably a billion lines of code, but still normal code.

There is AI in their world, like the doctor on Voyager, and the NPCs in the Holodeck. Notice how often there are problems with the AI, but never a problem with the computer (unless there's some external interference).