logoalt Hacker News

api • today at 12:50 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

The critique of capitalism would hit harder if it had competition. Ironically.

I look around the world. I see societies that are wealthy or developing where capitalism is running rampant. It sometimes calls itself other things (Chinese “communism”) or is organized in different ways but it’s capitalism running rampant.

Then I see poverty.

Then I see totalitarian managed economies of various kinds (theocracy, real communism) that are sometimes marginally better than poverty but basically poverty with guard rails.

Where is the successful alternatives?

I suppose you could reach for Northern Europe. But it’s basically capitalism running slightly less rampant with more safety net. Maybe that’s the pragmatic answer. But it’s not a different system, just a differently tuned instance of the same system.


Replies

throaway1985asd • today at 12:56 PM

Capitalism "works" because it allows economic production to remain in the hands of whoever created the venture. But when production starts to get centralized, and more and more production gets in the hands of fewer people, that ability to "work" gets lost.

➕ show 2 replies
sedictious • today at 1:20 PM

The existence to hyper-capitalism is not anti-capitalism and I never argued for a complete overhaul of the system, I think you are attacking an argument that is slightly different than mine.

In a lot of European countries we hit a sweet spot around the 60s to 80s (depends on how much plagued by poverty each country was after the war). Things were not prefect but there was a strong social net and strong unions (which have existed for far longer) that prioritised local production. Of course there is much more nuance than that and I can't condense the reality of halt the continent in a single paragraph, but it is very different to what we are experiencing now and it's still a "capitalist" society at its core. There is even a stark difference compared to two decades ago, where the process of globalisation and concentration of power to a vanishingly small minority was already evident

What you are seeing today is an echo of the past because we have reduced local production and are paying the price for this so you end up with a welfare state which is fueled by a service economy, which is almost self-evident why it is bad and a matter of time until the system collapses.

dns_snek • today at 4:15 PM

> Where is the successful alternatives?

Ruthlessly overthrown, murdered, or otherwise destroyed through meddling, slave labor, colonies, embargoes and sanctions by western colonialism and imperialism?

Even if someone discovered a perfect system we would never know because capitalism would destroy it first.

These discussions always devolve into "Economic system X is bad because country Y suffered Z" with a billion confounding variables affecting Z. Sometimes Z is a consequence of X, sometimes Z is caused by poor leadership of Y, sometimes it's caused by external natural disasters/resources, sometimes it's caused by direct meddling of hostile third parties who were ahead at that point in history for about a million different reasons.

What can we claim about the success of capitalism or failure of other economic systems that can't possibly be explained by "that's because capitalism was already dominant and hostile?"

➕ show 1 reply