logoalt Hacker News

delis-thumbs-7e • today at 3:56 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Let's do an experiment. Let's pretend you have a girl- or boyfriend. Now imagine something very upsetting happening at your workplace. Maybe you are threatened with an end of employment. You think about the prospect of job search in this economy and all the bills you need to pay. You message your spouse to talk about the situation and to seek some solace from the distress. Promptly your spouse answers with a sweet emphatic message, perfect to calm your current emotional turmoil. Almost too perfect. Then you realise it does not have single typo and is not really what they might say at all, although stylistically appears their writing. Instead of talking to you, they used an LLM to create a response. How does that make you feel?

Don't answer to me. Just answer to yourself.


Replies

jackling • today at 4:28 PM

I would feel fine, having something help you write isn't a moral failing. I assume my girlfriend here would've read through the message at the very least, and in this scenario, it did help me.

But lets say it made me feel terrible. I absolutely loathed it. I still wouldn't assume she's a sociopath or has some anti-social disorder. I would just tell her that I rather she write her own thoughts down versus getting them from a LLM. You know... what adults do? I would be curious to know why she thought she needed an LLM in the first place.

My comment wasn't saying that someone shouldn't be upset by the actions of the parent comments' friend, but your response is an incredible overreaction. Oddly enough, it exhibits some anti-social behaviour. Cutting someone off due to a single issue/disagreement isn't a normal thing to do. Diagnosing people with psychopathy is definitely strange.

➕ show 1 reply