So, I sued to think that, but I now reached the point of my self where there are many things in my life that I understand but can't explain.
First, because "understanding" is not the one size fit all word people think it is.
E.G: you understand riding a bike, but none of your explanations, no matter how detailed (and they are going to suck), are going to lead someone to bike.
Second, because communicating requires a channel, usually a common vocabulary and a shared set of experiences, to be able to exchange on the topic.
E.G: there are things that are such internal or personalized experience there is not much to transmit to the other party like some things that happen during meditation.
And both points at the same time: what the experience of seen is to a blind. Communication is useless. Knowing more about it (the frequency of light for example) is not going to help.
Third, they are just things that "you know". "You understand". "They are perfectly clear to you". You didn't gain this understanding; it emerged, or it seems like it was already there. You can use the fruit of this understanding in a perfectly fluent way, and there is no doubt in your mind, plus your experience has always confirmed it.
And yet, you can share that.
So yes, while the initial idea is true for many things, I'll add this 3 nuances.
Bike into the direction of tilt. It's an inverted pendulum. I could explain it to a Kindergartner. Just like balancing an upright racket on their hand takes some practice and standing upright takes some practice, balancing on a bike takes some practice to build the system 1 pathways to make the adjustments at low enough latency. That practice is not a matter of understanding.
> E.G: you understand riding a bike, but none of your explanations, no matter how detailed (and they are going to suck), are going to lead someone to bike.
> And both points at the same time: what the experience of seen is to a blind. Communication is useless. Knowing more about it (the frequency of light for example) is not going to help.
I think you're arguing against a point nobody is making, that the ability to explain something must also somehow faithfully transmit the ability for the other party to perfectly comprehend and replicate it for themselves. Indeed, that is probably never the case, for any idea or concept.
My reading of the argument is that it only really concerns your own comprehension of the concept, and the subsequent ability to distill it down to its essential bits, and not if the other party is in a position to comprehend it fully. For example, a good pastry chef could break down the concepts behind baking choux, in a way that another baker who's unfamiliar with it to understand the concept, maybe even replicate a decent version of it. It obviously isn't going to work if the other person has no concept of baking, or what an oven is. Your examples require all those background concepts and contexts to also be somehow transmitted in the explanation.