logoalt Hacker News

marky1991 • today at 4:23 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

Doesn't this argument reduce to "all things not strictly required for life that consume resources are immoral"?

If not, where are you drawing the fine lines?

A critic could allege that the claim is really "all things not strictly required for life that I don't value or appreciate that consume resources are immoral".


Replies

trashb • today at 4:57 PM

no, I am saying consider banning the outliers that bring huge consequences. This is normal behavior and we do this in every part of life.

I like cars, we ban cars from the road that pollute too much. I like racing cars, still it is illegal to race on the public road because it would be unsafe. Why shouldn't we extend the same thinking to cruise ships? Especially regarding they only provide entertainment with a clear alternative, go to a all inclusive hotel.

Let's not pretend like banning cruise ships will lead to banning "all things not strictly required for life" like going for a walk.

➕ show 2 replies
samwiseg • today at 4:28 PM

Slippery slope argument. The pollution of cruises is totally egregious. There is no line that need to be drawn.

➕ show 1 reply
marky1991 • today at 4:28 PM

Said another way, happiness itself is completely optional.

Who are you to decide what kinds of pursuits of happiness are prudent and reasonable and which are excessively wasteful and must be banned?

➕ show 1 reply