logoalt Hacker News

samwiseg • today at 4:36 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I like biking and birding and cooking. Sure all of it has a carbon impact. I travel to a different country for fun about once a year. That’s not necessary. But cruises are a crazy outlier in terms of pollution per person especially wrt utility/benefit to society


Replies

marky1991 • today at 4:44 PM

Here, you're making a utilitarian argument. But presumably for people that go on cruises, they get a lot of utility by going, they pay a lot of money to do it. On what basis are you judging the costs and benefits here?

I'm not aware of the details of this, what are the actual costs of sulfur oxide in the air?

And as always with utilitarian arguments, why is your evaluation function special?

If we were to just accept that "sulfur oxide is bad", then why wouldn't the obvious answer be "ban burning high sulfur gas", not "ban cruises"?