I've stayed pretty quiet about this, but as an early and enthusiastic Framework supporter, I cannot recommend them to anyone.
I bought the Framework 13 before launch, and received a machine from the first batch. I later bought their main board upgrade kit and their screen upgrade kit and I did a full upgrade on the machine and rebuilt it. The reason I could justify that was that I would take the old main board and slip it into their Cooler Master case and use it as a spare machine.
But there was a bug in the Intel chip they used in that main board that prevented it from booting properly inside of the Cooler Master case, and going back and forth with support, what they wanted me to do was disassemble my other computers to troubleshoot the one that should have just worked. They didn't offer a replacement. They didn't allow me to send it in to have them fix it. When I explained that I didn't want to disassemble my working machines to fix my broken machine, they stopped replying to me.
This, coupled with the horrendous battery issues in the first version of the Framework 13, led me to conclude another purchase from them would be a big mistake.
Still happy with all six of my System76 purchases.
> Still happy with all six of my System76 purchases.
I, on the other hand, wish I'd gone with a Framework instead of System76.
My System76 devices keep breaking and because they're a few years old already, obtaining replacement parts is a challenge. And forget about upgrading them or giving a laptop a second life as a desktop.
Here's my perspective because I recently became a framework owner of the 13 pro. Before then I'd bought a Dell XPS that came to me broken out of the box (keyboard was completely fubar).
The 13 pro has been a very good machine for me. Excellent battery life, good performance, just smooth sailing. My one criticism is the speakers are crap. I know they improved them, so I have to imagine the original 13 speakers were even worse.
The reason I grabbed the 13 pro was because framework featured an upgrade path from the original 13 to a 13 pro by swapping out relevant parts. That's what sold me.
Not an excuse for them, but you bought the very first product from a brand new company. They'd probably do better today.
For example, I bought the second and fourth(?) laptop they put out and am very happy with them. One issue was there was a problem with the power cable jacket opening up. Suppose support could be a bit faster but they sent a new one after I mailed a photo in.
Let it be a warning to everyone else, early product/early company, expect adventures. You're going to have to help them out, even to make them do the right thing. Believe they're capable of learning however, and don't think this "never again" rhetoric is helpful in that case.
Glad I avoided the hype on these and bought a trusty Thinkpad instead. Couldn't be happier.
> Still happy with all six of my System76 purchases.
Conversely, I'm a bit iffy on System 76. The main reason being, the build quality of the physical device. From a pure computing viewpoint it's fine. Maybe better than fine. But the case is really falling apart. Lots of cracks, and broken fan slats, and such-like. I mean, it still works and is usable, but it just doesn't feel like a high-quality build, so I'm not sure I'd buy from them again.
I think the tbf on this is that the very first 11th gen product was buggy in a way that later ones haven't been. My 12th gen has been error-free; my 13th gen was good until the motherboard died (which is a longevity problem, not that kind of bugginess); and my Pro is great so far.
Fully agree with you about the awfulness of the support, but I think the picture you paint of their hardware is too negative based on you having gotten the bad one.
I never understood this company. Comparable ThinkPads (at least until the rampocalypse) cost less and are pretty repairable/durable. Mac hardware knock on wood has never given out on me either. I remember seeing the YouTube reviews of the Framework 16 laptop, whichever one had the GPU, and you could tell they were really flimsy and had tons of chassis flex, but were being given a pass.
I'm on the boat for a second System76 pangolin now. My first one had a few faults but was the best laptop I owned.
> going back and forth with support, what they wanted me to do was disassemble my other computers to troubleshoot the one that should have just worked. They didn't offer a replacement. They didn't allow me to send it in to have them fix it. When I explained that I didn't want to disassemble my working machines to fix my broken machine, they stopped replying to me.
That completely tracks. I've found their support to be extremely lame at best.
You can literally see exactly what I bought and when I bought it but you still need me to crack open the case to get the serial number on the mainboard whose widespread, notorious defect you aren't going to repair, but instead offer a lame workaround part for me to install myself instead?
You need a recorded video of the lid of my laptop gradually sagging downward while I type before you can send replacement hinges under warranty, even though the defect is common and why the fuck would I want to scam you out of little fucking hinges that I need to install myself anyway ytvutyf023f498020923r8
Yeah.
What exactly do you expect from the first batch of first generation? Do you also own the first system76 product?
What the heck... I think I had the same issue as you a few months ago, 11th gen board, very early but maybe not pre-launch, and swapping in a $10 battery off Digikey fixed the "I need my AC adapter for it to boot at all" permanently.
And then I just yesterday did the Cooler Master swap, new mainboard into the laptop chassis, old mainboard as a server, and it went without a hitch, both machines running just fine.
I also don't know the battery issues you're referring to, I don't remember dealing with anything super horrendous in the 5 years I've been using this laptop, but my battery is currently in good shape, probably 6-8 hours on a full charge, which is impressive for a 5yo battery.
I did basically the same thing and I've had problems getting the main board to boot reliably. I've not needed it so haven't troubleshooted further. Discouraged it might be a show stopping bug. :(
S76 is awesome if you use Linux as primary OS. Stay away if you need Windows.
which System76 laptops do most people get? would it be the Ryzen (Pangolin or Oryx) ones?
Yeah I had the battery problem, had to get a new battery because the first one blew up like a pop tart and I now permanently keep the laptop at 60% charge tops. Are you saying my first cooked battery was not actually my fault ?
> there was a bug in the Intel chip they used in that main board that prevented it from booting properly inside of the Cooler Master case
How do you know that? Is this a known issue you ran in to? Or did it stop working after you swapped it out and then you refused to troubleshoot?
> bug in the Intel chip
It sounds like the problem was Intel's and not theirs, yrt they still went out of their way to help you.
Your mainboard fit in the Coolermaster case? Mine had a defect where the case's pegs were too large for the mainboard to fit over them. Framework sent a replacement, same issue. Framework sent a second replacement which they claimed was "white glove service", meaning they would have someone verify the quality of the part before shipping it. Same issue. I returned them all for a refund. Several others on the forum had the same issue.
I also went through 3 hinges on my 1st gen Framework 13 laptop, because the hinges were so weak they couldn't hold up the screen under its own weight.
My thread cataloguing my issues with the Framework 13 got so long, the moderators closed it.
My trackpad stopped detecting clicks. So did the replacement that I bought because it was out of warranty.
One of the buttons for the expansion card removal fell off. Framework replaced that under warranty.
The speakers would cause the keyboard to rattle until I took off the shift keys and adjusted the stabilizers.
I really wanted to believe in and support Framework. I support their mission. But man, everything I've gotten from them has been junk.