logoalt Hacker News

uecker • today at 4:39 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

It is also easy to write it wrong in other languages. The coreutils rewrite had hundreds of issues, cloudflare brought down half of the internet because in the magic language where nothing can go wrong due to the advanced type system someone used an unchecked .unwrap (but this does not count, because this was Rust and not C - so could not possibly be the fault of the language, so only the programmer is to blame), and just recently Microsoft found a couple of memory safety issues in Rust's standard library. And let's better not talk about the supply chain.


Replies

eptcyka • today at 9:07 PM

Most of those were crashes. The unsoundness in the standard library is a problem, but I am yet to see a practical impact of them.

Rust people do not shy away from criticism. But rust code typically need not worry about mismatched buffer sizes at library boundaries. Especially when it comes to rce enabling bugs.