logoalt Hacker News

ToucanLoucan • today at 4:44 PM • 8 replies • view on HN

Arguing the definition of original is pointless for the exact reason you point out: that it's ambiguous. Due to the nature of how an LLM works, it cannot make anything truly new, it, again, can only recombine and remix things from it's training data. This is why AI images/writing are so easily spotted, and even AI code to a degree: they have a distinct "style" as a consequence of how they work.

I leave what is truly original to the philosophers. What I can say for certain, is that anything you get out of any of these models is a remix of what is present in it's training data, because gravity exists and energy is conserved. They are not intelligent, they are not conscious, and they cannot make New things.


Replies

retsibsi • today at 4:55 PM

> What I can say for certain, is that anything you get out of any of these models is a remix of what is present in it's training data, because gravity exists and energy is conserved.

But doesn't that same argument apply to humans, where 'training data' = all our sensory inputs (plus what's encoded in our DNA, depending on whether we want to analogise that to the training data or the underlying architecture)?

> Arguing the definition of original is pointless for the exact reason you point out: that it's ambiguous.

I'm not trying to be a smartarse here but you are the one who is claiming absolute certainty that something is false 'by definition', so I think the onus really is on you to have a precise definition in mind.

> They are not intelligent, they are not conscious, and they cannot make New things.

I'm not a consciousness denier or anything, in fact I think it is the most important thing in the world, but I don't understand the connections you're making here. 'Intelligent', like 'original', can be defined and needs to be defined for this statement to be meaningful. 'Conscious' is probably inherently slippery, but if we mean the same thing by it (having subjective experience/qualia) then I have no idea how you could be certain that any other entity lacks it. And it seems like you may be implying that consciousness is a necessary condition for originality, but I don't think you've explained how.

jonahx • today at 5:36 PM

> Due to the nature of how an LLM works, it cannot make anything truly new, it, again, can only recombine and remix things from it's training data

Fwiw, David Hume made this exact argument about human imagination:

> But though our thought seems to possess this unbounded liberty, we shall find, upon a nearer examination, that it is really confined within very narrow limits, and that all this creative power of the mind amounts to no more than the faculty of compounding, transposing, augmenting, or diminishing the materials afforded us by the senses and experience. [David Hume — An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748), Section II, Paragraph 5]

WarmWash • today at 5:22 PM

Everything is either deterministic, random, or a mix of that.

New is just a mix of deterministic and random. LLMs are not deterministic.

You don't even need an LLM to create something new and improved. Evolutionary algorithms have been doing it since the 80's.

hardbass • today at 5:36 PM

Non answers are best ignored. You have failed to define what creativity is and therefore failed to prove whether llms are "creative" or not.

What exactly are you trying to say about gravity and thermodynamics? You may be confused but these are universal physical laws that apply to everything, humans, computers, anything else.

At its most basic level if I had to start with defining creativity, it should be some kind of intelligent filtering process. The brain can be in a huge number of state configurations, the interesting and novel among them are "creative" ideas. We can build upon it further. I am happy to say I am no philosopher and I will defer to those with expertise on it. But if you don't have any definition for it, its quite strange to make up some beliefs about it without proof.

drdeca • today at 5:51 PM

You’re the one who said “ By definition an LLM cannot create original work”, so I think responding asking for the definitions you are talking about is quite justified?

Often when someone says that something is true by definition, their claim is incorrect.

brookst • today at 6:03 PM

Does your same argument hold for humans’ inability to do more than remix? Gravity exists and energy is conserved for us, too.

CamperBob2 • today at 5:59 PM

Arguing the definition of original is pointless for the exact reason you point out: that it's ambiguous.

Well, it certainly wasn't "ambiguous" two posts ago when you said "Absolutely not. By definition an LLM cannot create original work." Make up your mind.

You've been beating this drum since roughly GPT 3.5, as I recall. Your goalposts aren't even on the field anymore, they're gathering dust in a far corner of the parking garage down the street from the stadium. Time to update your priors.