> Your definition; "a set is compact if and only if every open cover has a finite subcover", requires a lot of prior knowledge to actually make sense of.
That is seanhunter's entire point.Simple to who? Simple given what prior knowledge? Is a simple explanation one that can be understood with an elevator pitch? Over drinks? Over several days? Longer? And to what degree of accuracy? I can give you explanations for things and it'll be simple and yet different experts who do understand will argue over if it is a good enough explanation or not.
> Explain it in a way an attentive 5 years old kid could understand
So I don't think this Einstein misattribution is a meaningful bar. It isn't even about attention. Some concepts simply need a lot of prior knowledge to meaningfully understand. Believing a 5 year old could understand nearly everything were it explained well enough would suggest that expertise is an illusion. Yet expertise exists because complexity increases exponentially as understanding converges (all those little nuances end up mattering).Exactly, it just shows Kottke's truism/platitude is wrong and absurd and thus pedagogy should be left to actual experts, there is some irony that today only people who understand advanced math are experientially qualified to point out just how mistaken the OP title is.
I had no idea what any of that meant and your explanation did nothing at all but confuse me, and Claude explained it to me in a few minutes.
The example is terrible because they aren't explaining it, they are defining it. It's like asking to explain electricity and getting "it is the set of physical phenomena associated with the presence and motion of matter possessing an electric charge." That's not explaining it and no amount of effort on the part of the listener helps.