logoalt Hacker News

impulser_ • today at 5:03 PM • 8 replies • view on HN

I thought Lovable was aimed for non developers, but apparently not so I'm confused on why anyone building an app would use this over Claude Code, Codex, OpenCode, or any agent harness.

Like this feature is just a prompt in any coding agent with any modern LLM.


Replies

stefanfisk • today at 8:06 PM

I'm a developer who consults for a company who don't have their own devs but whom have started experimenting with building misc little apps in Lovable to solve business needs. I have spent a fair amount of time trying to get them into Claude Code instead so that they can prototype in our main codebase rather than vibe coding separate little apps for everything, but it really is an uphill battle and at this point I'm not even sure that it would be the right call.

Lovable is just waaay easier to use for a novice, because the workflow is stricter and a lot more directed. There's a chat and a preview side by side by default, and the interface is entirely modeled around directly building something simple for the web.

Claude can do everything Lovable can and much much more, but you have to know what to ask for and it's quite easy to go off the rails if you don't. Without any experience with branching, what would you even ask for? I've seen examples of Claude just starting to modify the main branch and without committing while working because a prompt was worded a bit wrong. But vague or confusing prompts are to be expected when the person prompting has never had to learn even the most basic common language around developer workflows.

➕ show 1 reply
jmathai • today at 6:40 PM

I think that's downplaying the end-to-end automation here. You might be able to prompt Claude to clone your environment. But in reality, the bigger value is when that capability is baked in to the system (in this case it's Lovable, in mine it's the skills/context/etc I have set up).

It's not trivial, IMO, to have a system that has all of the rules codified and that's what Lovable is offering here and the premise of their entire product.

How people use Claude Code is such a wide spectrum.

toddmorey • today at 6:59 PM

I don’t use lovable, but this is more than a code branch or worktree, it’s a complete working deployment populated with sample data. I think that feature makes a ton of sense (maybe even more sense) for non-devs.

And for any software or app now, every feature is “just a prompt in any coding agent with any modern LLM”. That’s the new world we occupy.

rimeice • today at 7:22 PM

The dev, non dev binary paradigm is much blurry than it used to be. “Non devs” get a lot of “dev” concepts now. Basic understanding of how the tech we use works is much more common than it used to be and effectively a requirement for most professional jobs given its central to how most customers interact with most businesses nowadays. You just can’t be an effective operator without the basic understanding.

jaccola • today at 5:16 PM

People were saying this about Perplexity and Cursor for months to over a year. I still see the odd story about Perplexity even now.

The time between the fatal blow and death is just surprisingly long. Hopefully Lovable can get bought out by a SpaceX (seems Perplexity might not be so lucky).

➕ show 1 reply
swedishuser • today at 5:59 PM

I’ve never used Lovable, but I’m guessing the selling point is that you get everything in one place and it just works while also taking proper security measures. App code, DB, hosting, domain etc in a working package and on a single invoice.

I would be really interested in knowing what premium you pay for all this if anyone knows roughly.

➕ show 1 reply
ibn_khaldun • today at 5:39 PM

Non-developers still need to know where to put their app if they aren't inquisitive enough to ask the LLM and/or industrious enough to deploy it themselves.

➕ show 1 reply
j45 • today at 8:19 PM

It's worth trying out to answer your own question - it has it's own strengths in other areas.