logoalt Hacker News

vcryan • today at 5:07 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

The premise seems odd to me.

1. If a person can devise a method of using AI for generating code why can they not devise automated methods of reliably verifying code?

2. I guess we can create a new job title of professional code reviewer - but without that I don't know how teams would keep up with the volume of code review when someone can open 10-100 PRs per day.

3. Do we believe human are good at code review, generally? I do not. When AI or other automated approaches are compared to humans reviewing code it seems like the comparison is towards this idealized amazing accurate human code reviewer but in our experience - such people exist - but they are far outnumbered by careless code reviewers.

Probably obvious from my comments - but I'm not planning to read much code anymore in my career. Seems like a waste of time when it can be generated and verified (adequately) through various automations. I understand that good verification doubles or triples the time of generating code - still way way faster than people being directly involved.


Replies