logoalt Hacker News

0xBA5ED • today at 5:08 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

"the entire world is wrong?" This does happen you know. Groupthink is a real phenomenon. Choosing to think something because it's the popular opinion is the exact moment when it begins.


Replies

bluegatty • today at 5:47 PM

I indicated as much.

You're conflating 'groupthink' and 'magical thinking'.

An arbitrary contrarian idea is not evidence of 'groupthink'

'Groupthink' is common - more common that not.

The 'Gell-Mann Amnesia effect' alludes to this - whenever someone with expertise reads about something in the press related to their expertise - they realize 'the media has it wrong' - but they continue to 'trust the media' on all other matters.

That's nuanced, but observable.

But in most cases - public narratives or common misconceptions are easily remedied with a few basic facts.

A military expert could quickly dispell misconceptions about 'how the war in Iran is actually going'.

In the case of AI - it's true that we probably have a common misunderstanding or intuition for how it works.

That does not mean the OPs imperious claim has any validity.