logoalt Hacker News

tlb • today at 5:21 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I don't think fair comparisons are really possible across different processes. There's a lot of interaction between silicon process, architecture, and workload.

The fairest comparison is between chips from major vendors in the same year. If you're just doing FP32 matrix multiplies, a 2026 nVidia GPU is ~1 pJ / FLOP, an Apple M4 is ~30 pJ, and a 2026 Intel Xeon is ~50 pJ. The quality of process and optimization is a little different between those 3 companies, but not by as much as 2x. But from those numbers, you can reliably conclude that the GPU architecture is much better for matrix multiplies.


Replies

kragen • today at 7:03 PM

Yes, that is surely true. What about small in-order scalar cores like the PULPino? Maybe the M4 and Xeon are spending a lot of those picojoules on OoO, caches, speculative execution, etc.