Christ. How hard can it be... If it's broken on arrival, you take it back immediately, no questions asked. And preferably, you send a replacement before you've even received an ack on that, especially if it's a repeat customer.
Sounds like no one ever thought to ask "how much patience does our customers have?" and "how much patience does this particular customer have left?"
I have zero tolerance for dealings like this, and once you're on my blacklist no amount of press releases about improved processes and a hired CxO who be sure to take care of it going forward will get you off of it.
That said, I still respect Framework for what they're trying to do, and from what I hear, the hardware is great when it works. I hope they can get their act together on the business side too.
Back in the 90s I did technical support for Winbook laptops (owned by Micro Electronics, Inc at the time if there are any MicroCenter fans in here).
We had this abusively absurd policy that if a brand new laptop was shipped DoA, the *customer* had to pay to ship it back and had to wait until the new laptop was repaired and shipped back to them. In 18 months there I never saw us pay for return shipping and I never saw us cross-ship a laptop. Keep in mind some of these configurations were closing in on $5k in 1995 dollars.
This was not a particularly uncommon issue either, unfortunately. The dread I would feel when a customer would open with 'So I just received my laptop'. xD