logoalt Hacker News

ray__ • today at 5:27 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

Not a comment on the work itself, but I am disappointed by the style and tone of this paper. It's hard to take a piece of academic research seriously with headers like "Welcome to the Era of Self-Rewriting." Even the logos next to the affiliations are enough to give me pause.

I've noticed this trend in my own sub-field, where companies are frequently releasing "preprints" or "white papers" that are simply marketing pieces, with experiments that lack controls or appropriate benchmarks and just generally misrepresent the work at hand. It's already a significant undertaking to read a paper like this and actually understand it, even if you're in the field—I'm not going to commit an hour of my valuable mental energy to it if it is a press release in disguise.

The work should speak for itself. There is a lot of trust involved in any paper like this, and if the authors feel the need to editorialize the message, how can I trust that the data aren't editorialized as well?