logoalt Hacker News

650REDHAIR • today at 5:28 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I will never give Dell another dime.

My XPS 15 had 3 battery failures. 2 Under warranty.

After the 3rd failure I tried to find a third party replacement (because of the Dell track record and the fact that Dell was sold out of the battery at that time...) only to find out Dell has battery DRM and won't charge non-OEM batteries. Basically the machine would boot and stay on until the initial charge died- super cool.

My MacBooks and ThinkPads are workhorses... If given a Dell I would sell it to fund a used ThinkPad.


Replies

FireBeyond • today at 8:27 PM

Sure, but I've been fucked by Apple too.

I had a MBP with the screen delamination issue - Apple didn't care, called it cosmetic, until after I'd got rid of it and decided it was an issue.

I had a MBP that had the mainboard issue - I could reliably and repeatedly make a fresh OS install kernel crash on apple.com in Safari, in front of the Genius, but because it passed their diagnostic tool, sucks to be me.

Butterfly keyboard issues.

An MBA that had a charging circuit issue with small water ingress on the magsafe port? Laptop works fine, Apple and third party battery diagnostics report battery healthy, just can't be charged. Go to Apple, expecting something reasonable? $300, maybe, after time and materials?

"We have a quote for you, it will be $950..." (to repair a $999 laptop!) "Perhaps we should get you looking at a new Mac instead..."

close04 • today at 6:32 PM

I’m a long time user of IBM and then Lenovo laptops going back decades. Just wait until you find out how Lenovo machines have a WiFi card whitelist so you can’t install whatever model you want. Or that on AMD machines they use PSB which locks the CPU to a Lenovo board, and if you don’t disable it and install a new CPU you are one Enter key away from locking the new one too, after they present you with a misleading “want to secure your CPU” message. And these are just the issues that are the result of conscious hostile decisions. Apple has the same problems with user hostile decisions and 0 repairability.

You also have less intentional issues. A lot of their X1 line generations were terrible, problematic screens, poor cooling, battery issues, BIOS issues, etc. Not just on 1 or 2 devices, but problems that I could see on batches of thousands or more. Apple devices were for years infamous for screen, GPU, keyboard issues, cooling issues (the last Intel models were something special, to put the last IBM models to shame) and so on.

Nobody collects full reliability statistics on the big manufacturers because the data isn’t available so you have to hope that when you buy from a line of laptops you didn’t land on the problematic one.

In the past few years I had better luck with Dell than Lenovo (again, talking large scale, for my use I stuck with some older Lenovo models).

I’m a bit soured with Lenovo ATM after buying a desktop to scavenge the PRO line APU (for the ECC support), wondering for a hot second why it’s so much cheaper than an identical HP, only to find out the CPU can’t be used on any non Lenovo system. Bought another equivalent HP which runs cooler and consistently moderately faster.