> I don't understand why this isn't 'alright, pack it up and ship it and we'll send you a replacement'.
Oh no. It should be "we have sent you a replacement - once it's installed and confirmed working, pack up the broken one and send us in the provided box with the provided pre-paid return label".
Best thing about Dell for example, with an enterprise contract you can overnight parts based on a machines service tag and they come with a prepaid return label, super easy and simple.
I'm fine with a middle ground - either run the support questions/tests and get the prepaid advance RMA, or say "I know what the fucking problem is, give me the advance RMA and bill me for shipping if the returned part is fine and I'm a dumbass."
In reality many people will NOT take the second option, but will be happy it was there, and the company probably never bothers billing for incorrect advance RMAs.