logoalt Hacker News

simgt • today at 5:35 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I had exactly the same experience with the Desktop. PSU has a design fault, new units still ship with that fault a year after release, and customer support still asks for proof, offer all sorts of potential fixes to try and finally a full one hour procedure for a replacement of the part by another faulty one. Meanwhile a third party managed to design a better PSU for their product. It's astonishing. [0]

[0] https://community.frame.work/t/noisy-psu-fan/74751


Replies

bityard • today at 6:37 PM

First, I think it's dumb that Framework stuck a semi-generic PSU in the Desktop with a tiny little buzzy fan and no way to control it _while_ marketing the machine as nearly silent. Poor design and bad marketing.

Buuuut, I'll argue against the point that these are faulty units. Everyone gets the same PSU in their Desktop. That thread (and many others like it) are full of people claiming that their _specific_ PSU fan is loud and defective and demanding that Framework should replace it. And then are surprised when the replacement sounds exactly like the old one.

I bought the Framework Desktop anyway after reading these threads, and after owning it for almost a year, I have to say that the fan noise doesn't actually bother me. I have had laptops and desktops with FAR noisier fans that ran either constantly or intermittently so I guess I'm just thankful that modern PCs don't sound like vacuum cleaners anymore.