logoalt Hacker News

chriswarbo • today at 5:48 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

The main problem with geoengineering is not the unintended consequences, the unknown unknowns, etc. It's that it would require massive, coordinated effort.

The reason I say that's the main problem, is because that's also the main problem with reducing fossil fuel usage.

It's fun to debate the technical details of geoengineering (solar shades, atmospheric aerosols, enhanced weathering, etc.), in the same way that it's fun to debate the technical details of carbon reduction (energy storage methods, approaches to electrical transmission, remote work, land use, etc.).

But none of that really matters if we, collectively, don't actually do anything! It's not as fun as comparing scifi fantasies, but the problem we need to solve is that of getting humanity to actually do something, at scale, which is collectively acknowledged as necessary yet is not immediately/individually profitable.

If we could solve that, then we could do geoengineering; but in such a world, we might not need to, because we could also do carbon reduction, plus a bunch of other stuff!

However, if we can't solve that, then geoengineering is an illusion.

It's a grass-is-greener fallacy: what makes any geoengineering project seem remotely feasible, in a world where we can't even coordinate on the obviously-a-good-idea stuff?


Replies

ACCount39 • today at 6:28 PM

Reduction is far, far, far worse on the "coordinated effort" front.

Geoengineering can be carried out by a single country unilaterally. That's the geoengineering edge.

Emissions have to be solved by every major country, and in coordination - otherwise, economics favor whoever neglects to do it. That's a coordination task orders of magnitude more severe. If your argument against geoengineering is "coordination", then you should be forsaking "emission reduction driven by political action" ten times over. Same goes for "carbon capture at scale."

The only tool that leaves you with is "emission reduction driven by economic forces." Which may well be sufficient. But I'd rather not leave tools on the table.

➕ show 1 reply
tito • today at 8:57 PM

When you say massive coordinated effort, say more about that. There’s definitely a spectrum of different solutions. Some of them look like things humanity has built in the past. Others look like things we haven’t ever built before. Curious what you’re seeing out there.

LightBug1 • today at 6:00 PM

We've been geoengineering and not giving a shit about unintended consequences for the last 200 years.

Why change the habit of a species? Just saying.

Clutching at our pearls at this stage just seems a bit ... ridiculous considering what's gone on.

➕ show 1 reply