logoalt Hacker News

nater5000 • today at 6:01 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Not sure why this nonsense is being upvoted lol

>those thinking it is are literally failed educations

What? What does this mean? I feel like I'm having a stroke reading this.

>AGI requires artificial comprehension

It requires artificial general intelligence. Like, trivially. You're choosing to define AGI in a specific way that isn't based on any foundation that is universally accepted.

>When we have artificial comprehension there will be no need to train AIs beyond the kindergarten school basics, and then the AGI will figure it all out, all the rest, on its own.

Ok? I can buy that what you're describing would be pretty powerful, but how is this a requirement for "general intelligence"? Am I not generally intelligent despite learning much of the knowledge I use from others? I've built a career out of stuff I learned through "human literature," am I literally just unintelligent because I didn't figure out everything on my own?

And shouldn't such a capable system not even need "kindergarten school basics"? Why is that the minimum amount of knowledge you find acceptable to explicitly teach such an AI while still considering it a general intelligence?

>Human history and human literature will need to be learned in reference, but science and mathematics will require no training, beyond to learn the names of concepts we discovered earlier, so the AGI can discuss its understandings with humans and other AGI.

I guess I don't see why what we have now is fundamentally different from whatever it is you're imagining. If an AI can produce novel scientific findings, then isn't that sufficient for saying that it is generally capable at making scientific findings? Sure, we've bootstrapped it as much as possible, but do you not agree that LLMs seem capable of scientific discovery?

Seems like you've just concocted a wish list and have attributed your strict definition of AGI as some fundamental source of truth. I'd argue that what you're describing is much stronger than "AGI" and would likely warrant a label like ASI instead.

To me (and most people?) AGI is simply an AI system that is reasonably capable of general work. It doesn't go deeper than that. If it can meet the expectations of "general intelligence" (the same way you could describe a human as being "generally intelligent"), then it is AGI by definition.

It's fine to argue what the criteria for "general intelligence" should be, and you can even assert that you don't think AI will achieve a reasonable "general intelligence" without whatever foundation you're describing, but it doesn't make sense to argue that the general intelligence of a given system is the "wrong" kind of general intelligence and therefore doesn't deserve the title because it isn't a more powerful version of a general intelligence.


Replies

nomel • today at 8:34 PM

> To me (and most people?) AGI is simply an AI system that is reasonably capable of general work.

I think the ability to learn, in a "modify the latent space" sense (weight change) rather than a "point to a different existing latent space" (context result), is part of most people's definition.

But, even then, you could claim these models are doing that, just in very slow time scales. Human somewhat do it awake, but mostly do it while sleeping. LLM do it between version releases, while dreaming about past user conversations. ;) I've seen some people claim that they meet some definition of "sentience" during these training sessions, because of this, which probably has some merit.

Regardless, it's all clearly some scale, rather than a binary. The proof is in the pudding, so it seems silly to argue about any of this. We'll know it's far past AGI, meeting everyones mushy, opinionated, definitions, when these conversations stop happening.