logoalt Hacker News

ohazi • today at 6:21 PM • 10 replies • view on HN

> At Rebel, we score every YC startup and founder across hundreds of dimensions using our proprietary Rebel Theorem 5.0 ML/AI model, looking at everything from founder education and work backgrounds, personality traits, archetypes, entrepreneurial track record, founder-product fit, and more.

Gross.


Replies

lispisok • today at 8:23 PM

Isnt the point of entrepreneurship to blaze your own trail? Seems like machine learning algorithm trained on past entrepreneurs would inherently fail at identifying new ones.

kylecazar • today at 6:31 PM

The whole idea behind the fund seems incredibly lazy.

But the name "Rebel Theorem 5.0 ML/AI model" makes me suspect they are full of shit.

➕ show 1 reply
bretpiatt • today at 6:38 PM

How would you prefer investment decisions to be made? Looks like there's a market for quant analysis where LPs respect what they're doing and companies are good to have them as investors.

We do stuff differently at Redbud Trail Group in alignment with what our LPs are looking for. VCs are just like any other two sided marketplace business trying to build a differentiated offering to both founders and LPs.

➕ show 2 replies
rimeice • today at 7:07 PM

I don’t understand pre series a investors that do this. If you need an algorithm to tell you a founder is good or not you are in precisely the wrong job.

➕ show 1 reply
close04 • today at 6:58 PM

They say they score the startups and founders but the startup or the product itself maybe fit under “and more”. They rate how determined the founders are to make money at any cost, not the startup, the idea, or the product.

sl0wbrainRot • today at 6:49 PM

Yeah this feels like Halo Effect applied to a spec sheet based on common founder attributes

Goodhart's law needs to come for VC/startup funds

It's 100% lazy "Excel sheet driven" decision making, not a good measure for quality relative to ground truth

nylonstrung • today at 7:31 PM

There's no ML model capable of reliably producing usable predictions from such high cardinality qualitative data so this is almost certainly just an LLM prompt + data scraped from LinkedIn or Pitchbook.

Even if we pretend it isn't just copywriting to scam LPs, the entire idea is that smart VC bets on founders should be made on the most public, surface level information rather than the subtle tells and cues that come up from diligence and interactions with founders.

In other words, the thesis is to just make decisions like a first year sourcing analyst rather than an experienced, talented Partner.

pavel_lishin • today at 7:45 PM

Not brainpan diameter, birth sign, or favorite Power Ranger?

gradus_ad • today at 6:46 PM

Let's run it on the Rebel founder and team.

benatkin • today at 7:47 PM

Weird that they'd be looking for a founder like Brian Armstrong or a team like Collision Brothers.

Actually, not weird.