logoalt Hacker News

nostrademons • today at 8:04 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

The game theory behind MAD has two major preconditions behind it:

1) There are not so many nuclear-armed states that one country can launch an attack and have enough country blamed for it. Likewise, there are not so many nuclear-armed states that one country might launch nukes by accident or irrationality.

2) All nuclear armed states have a future, i.e. there is no nuclear-armed power that is facing an existential threat other than nuclear weapons.

#1 is the wisdom behind nuclear non-proliferation, and why all nuclear-armed powers do everything they can to prevent other states or non-state actors (like terrorist groups) from getting nuclear weapons. If there is ever a situation where a suitcase nuke goes off in Washington or Moscow and they aren't sure who did it, the world ends. The set of nuclear-armed powers initially started with the 5 members of the UN Permanent Security Counsel and since then has expanded by Israel, India, Pakistan, and North Korea, with Iran being widely suspected of being close. You see similar examples of cartel-collapse (another MAD situation, with lower stakes) when the number of participants reaches about 10 - notably, one mechanism by which OPEC prices often collapse is when smaller member states secretly overproduce and Saudi Arabia has to cut to make up the difference. Another mechanism is when new firms enter the market without any incentive to maintain the existing detente (eg. the U.S. entering the oil market with the fracking boom of the early 2010s, or Facebook blowing up the high tech wage-fixing cartel by poaching everybody's employees with generous stock grants).

#2 follows from the finite/infinite game distinction. As long as the payoff for launching nukes is destruction of your state, there's a strong incentive not to do it. But if your state is gone anyway, and launching a war of aggression gives you a chance of not dying, the incentives flip. A (non-nuclear, but business) example of this was the patent detente among major tech companies in 2010, "and then Nokia launched the missiles". They were facing bankruptcy anyway, launching a bunch of patent troll lawsuits gave them a potential way out, and if everybody else retaliated, the worst that would happen is they go bankrupt, which was happening anyway.

I've heard a number of geopolitical analysts speculate that the Russia/Ukraine war was driven by exactly this: Russia's terrible demographics following the post-Soviet collapse, compounded by the death toll from COVID, meant that they will no longer have the capacity to wage war as an advanced industrialized power within 5-10 years, and so it was now or never. Climate change is another very obvious trigger for why a state may end up default-dead and hence have nothing to lose from starting WW3.