logoalt Hacker News

And Yet, It Moves

15 points • by notfried • today at 8:07 PM • 6 comments • view on HN

Comments

jdw64 • today at 9:23 PM

Maybe now we need to understand the world based on the things that move nonetheless.

In fact, programming at the application layer isn’t fully understanding the low level internally either—it’s working by trusting the API, so to me it doesn’t seem particularly strange. In applications, when an API leaks, you look at the low level, but usually that rarely happens. You only need to look in when there’s an outage.

The key point now is that clinging to formal verification like Lean/Coq is probably for the same reason. Maybe it works that way? After proving mathematics through Lean and formal verification, if a problem arises later, Lean and Coq find the wrong point again.

To borrow Dijkstra’s words, a smart programmer knows the size of his own skull. In the end, I think what matters is recognizing your cognitive limits and finding the best you can do within them.

aaron_m04 • today at 8:45 PM

We don't have to resign ourselves to this. We can use every means in our power to stop "AI".

jason_oster • today at 8:55 PM

It is absolutely absurd to claim that AI proofs and discoveries are not human achievements. The artificial mind was designed by humans, and the machine that runs the mind was built by humans. It isn't alien technology or an insect hive mind that did these things. The achievement is so human it hurts.

Invoking the Copernican principle in the same breath as lamenting the end of human achievement is ... I don't even have a word for it. Ignorant? The egocentrism is maddening.

paulddraper • today at 8:39 PM

1. It is better to see the world as it is, than any other version.

2. Gratitude is profoundly the greatest key to a well-adjusted outlook.

fh973 • today at 9:07 PM

And yet, a man can kill a lion.