logoalt Hacker News

devindotcom • today at 8:58 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

you really have an axe to grind. lorenzo uses signal you know.


Replies

autoexec • today at 9:10 PM

I was a fan. I recommended signal several times. That changed once they started keeping data in the cloud, and once they refused to update their policy I contacted as many of the people I'd recommended the app to as I could. Before that my biggest gripe was when they stopped allowing both secure messages and unsecured sms/mms.

Either the company is intentionally misleading people who are in very sensitive situations (including activists and whistleblowers whose lives and/or freedom can be at stake) or they're doing their best to warn people away from using their service as loudly as they can by not updating their privacy policy.

In either case, because I continue to see people using and recommending signal unaware of the new data collection practices and/or signal's failure to inform users of their actual risks while using the app, I do my best to make sure more people are aware so they can make an informed choice for themselves according their circumstances.

If Lorenzo is cool with the data they collect and keep in the cloud, and how they're doing it, that's great. Every user should have that opportunity, but right now it takes a fair amount of digging to uncover the lies being told in the polices they've published on the website.