logoalt Hacker News

throwaway48476yesterday at 11:12 PM5 repliesview on HN

One of the biggest problems with ATC hiring is that location assignments happen after trainees pass the academy. A lot of the academy graduates quit when they get an assignment they don't like. It's not like the military where they can force people. The trainee pay also sucks so the prospect of getting sent somewhere undesirable and then barely being able to afford it just isn't attractive. If they would hire based on location like they used to graduates wouldn't quit as often.

The other big problem is Obama changed the hiring test from testing intelligence to testing personality in a bid to increase diversity. There was a lawsuit over this. The effect was academy failure rates soared and because class sizes are fixed there was a shortfall in the number of graduates making it to towers to train.


Replies

jmulltoday at 11:17 AM

[flagged]

show 1 reply
Havoctoday at 1:02 AM

Why the hell would you test for personality or intelligence. Surely the key skill here is calm under pressure and stress?

show 3 replies
decimalenoughtoday at 12:25 AM

This is indeed a thing that happened, but blaming "Obama" personally for it is absurd, it was entirely the FAA's fuckup.

show 3 replies
philwelchyesterday at 11:40 PM

> The other big problem is Obama changed the hiring test from testing intelligence to testing personality in a bid to increase diversity. There was a lawsuit over this.

It was even worse than that. What they actually did was write up a phony “personality test” and distribute the answer key to applicants who were members of preferred racial organizations.

https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/the-full-story-of-the-fa...

show 2 replies
FridayoLearyyesterday at 11:34 PM

Another problem you haven't mentioned is the level of union control in the industry. Which is great as far as protecting jobs and salaries for existing controllers but it makes getting a desirable position difficult for a new graduate. From your comment it sounds like they just get dumped with the least desirable location until they've climbed high enough up the totem pole to get a good job.

show 5 replies