logoalt Hacker News

troupolast Friday at 10:48 AM2 repliesview on HN

> So you are saying that Array.from(querySelectorAll) gets you there? What are you missing then?

Array.from adds friction. The need to wrap querySelector in null checks adds friction. The fact that they are not composable in any way, shape, or form, with any DOM methods (and that DOM methods are not composable) adds friction.

jQuery was the fore-runner of fluid interface design. Nothing in the DOM before, then, or since ever thought about it. Even the new APIs are all the same 90s Java-style method calls with awkward conversions and workarounds to do anything useful.

That's why sites like "You don't need jQuery" read like bad parody: https://youmightnotneedjquery.com

E.g. what happens when it's not just one element?

   $(el).addClass(className);

   // vs.

   el.classList.add(className);

Or: why doesn't NodeList expose an array-like object, but provides an extremely anaemic interface that you always need to convert to array? [1]

   $(selector).filter(filterFn);

   // vs.

   [...document.querySelectorAll(selector)].filter(filterFn);

There's a reason most people avoid DOM APIs like the plague.

---

[1] This is the entirety of methods exposed on NodeList https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/NodeList

Instance properties

- length

Instance methods

- entries() // returns an iterator

- forEach()

- item()

- keys()

- values()


Replies

jraphlast Friday at 12:48 PM

I agree that DOM lists not being real arrays is a pita. I can understand why for getElementBy* methods which return live lists, but it's less clear for those methods returning fixed lists.

But to me, these are minor inconveniences and habits. A thin wrapper can get you there easily if you care enough. I personally dislike this array/element confusion that jQuery adds.

show 1 reply
WorldMakerlast Friday at 4:05 PM

You don't need Array.from if you are using `for (const x of document.querySelectorAll(selector) { }` loops anyway or have a library like IxJS handy.

ES2025 added map, filter, flatMap, reduce, forEach, and several other methods to all iterators (including NodeList directly, I believe, but definitely its entries(), keys(), values(), if not) [1]. It'll be a year or two at current pace before that is "widely accepted baseline" in browsers, but it's great progress on these sorts of complaints.

[1] https://2ality.com/2025/06/ecmascript-2025.html#iterator-hel...

show 1 reply