logoalt Hacker News

H-Bomb: A Frank Lloyd Wright typographic mystery

136 pointsby mrngmlast Thursday at 9:18 AM37 commentsview on HN

Comments

zemtoday at 9:23 AM

I will admit I lost interest after it was revealed that the letters had been replaced several times and that the original was most likely correct. "frank lloyd wright messed up the orientation of an H" has a bit of interest to it; "some random later person messed it up" has none.

show 1 reply
gylterudtoday at 5:24 PM

Not sure why the comments here are so negative! I found it mildly interesting, and worth a few minutes on a Sunday!

chris_engeltoday at 10:08 AM

Nobody speaks about the way larger spacing between "AND THE" in comparison to the other spaces...

II2IItoday at 5:13 PM

I don't understand why the author is intent on pinning the ever changing orientation of the letters on architects. Wright's intent would have been in the architectural drawings. Everything after that, including the original installation, would be the responsibility of the person who installed the lettering. I've seen much more obvious errors (e.g. spelling errors) occur during the installation of similar signage ... things that would not have made it to the final architectural drawings.

parpfishtoday at 4:33 AM

Im curious if the mounting points for the letters had 180deg rotational symmetry. If they didn’t (such as a mount point on the crossbar in the H), that’d go a long way to explaining “correctness”.

show 1 reply
greggsytoday at 4:32 AM

I was initially interested but after skimming through I questioned if this pedantic detective tale needed to be told…

Just send an email to the board of trustees / body corporate and move on.

show 1 reply
maratctoday at 5:24 PM

The typeface that is used there is not something typical, and it's very top-heavy in letters like P and R. The top-heavy H (called "upside-down" in the article) does not seem too odd in this context. F on the other hand is almost "normal".

vessenestoday at 3:00 AM

For the love of all this is holy, do not read this article. If the internet has taught has anything, it's that you cannot unsee an image - I predict you will not be able to unsee upside-down H's (and even an S) post-reading. Save yourself.

show 4 replies
weinzierltoday at 9:42 AM

Given that there had been wrongly installed letters continuously since at least 1956 and we have no proof that an entirely "correct" version ever existed, I'd consider the inverted H historically accurate and I hope it won't ever get fixed and especially not as an overreaction to the article.

show 1 reply
jsdaltontoday at 2:13 AM

I was more bothered by the extraneous word spacing on the second line, between “and” and “the.” Is it just me?

show 1 reply
knallfroschtoday at 8:19 AM

All this because some guys installed the letters wrong?

Is this some kind of joke, or is the author really lost in some conspiracy-level detail tracking, hunting for "hidden signals"?

show 1 reply
nacozarinatoday at 8:50 AM

ppl with this sort of mania should be allowed to collect disability and stay home

show 1 reply
brudgerslast Friday at 9:55 PM

I would not be surprised if the manufactured letters and their installation was based on hand hand drawn letters.

That it is not aesthetically obvious, suggests it was drawn that way and not a mistake. Good typography is subtle and bespoke typography even more so.

show 1 reply