logoalt Hacker News

AuryGlenzyesterday at 2:03 PM5 repliesview on HN

Pretty much every bill that has ever been put forward for needing an ID to vote has had a provision for free IDs. That’s not where things get caught up.

Also, it’s a pretty silly thing anyways. I don’t even drink and I still need my driver’s license quite a few times every year.


Replies

d1sxeyesyesterday at 5:30 PM

Even if the ID is nominally free, if I have to take a day off and pay for bus/train tickets to wait in line at some office, it’s not really free.

show 4 replies
servercobrayesterday at 7:35 PM

While Wisconsin was debating this, they also closed a bunch of DMVs and limited hours for other ones.

The WI constitution enshrines the ability to vote. So you may think it's silly and for 99% of people it may be silly, but if anyone is prevented from voting because there's not a reasonable way for them to get a license, their rights are being infringed.

stetrainyesterday at 4:21 PM

Free and accessible are not the same thing. And a driver's license is not necessarily proof of citizenship.

show 1 reply
TSiegeyesterday at 7:11 PM

> Pretty much every bill that has ever been put forward for needing an ID to vote has had a provision for free IDs.

Do you have a source for this because I have seen very few laws like this and runs counter to the overt intention of these laws

show 2 replies
lokaryesterday at 5:19 PM

The current bill Trump is pushing for requires "documentary proof of citizenship ", this can actually be very hard. It means an original/certified birth certificate, as well as any subsequent name changes (mostly married women).

This is completely unnecessary.

We establish citizenship, very reliably, at time of registration. This is on of the main jobs of the registrar of voters. They have plenty of time to look up the details of the person and establish citizenship (and intentionally lying in this process is a serious crime).

We then establish identity at the time of voting, again, very reliably.

Intentional voter impersonation or voting when not eligible is vanishingly rare in the US.

show 2 replies