alt Hacker NewsYou're being too charitable to Anthropic, and assuming that the way they are abusing the word "distillation" has some real meaning here. It doesn't.
Anthropic's models simply do not give you their reasoning output - they give a sanitized "summary" instead, for this exact reason, so that the output is not useful to anyone who might want to use it for training.
You can't distill what you are not given - simple as that.
Are Chinese using the output of US models to help create some additional training data for their own in some way? Yes - quite possibly (e.g. LLM as judge), but its got nothing to do with distillation.
Replies
> Anthropic's models simply do not give you their reasoning output - they give a sanitized "summary" instead, for this exact reason, so that the output is not useful to anyone who might want to use it for training.
This is just straight-up factually false.
The output of a reasoning model is immensely valuable even without the sanitized summary of the reasoning process - that Anthropic's service does expose to you, making it even more valuable.
There's absolutely nothing about the distillation process that requires that reasoning in the first place, either. That's a definition that you made up.
Chinese models are, factually, distilled from Anthropic models. I've personally repeatedly asked several different Chinese LLMs what their name is, and they answered "Claude".
Don't make stuff up to suit a political agenda. It's extremely dishonest.
I see your 'fine point' but I don't think it holds - 'distillation' is a perfectly reasonable term to describe the process of creating outputs from one model to that expose key training element, to use in another model.
I think where the definition may be be invalid, is in the creation of 'unrelated data sets for training' models, for unrelated issues.
Creating training sets that mach a models core training, is definitely distillation, it does not have to expose the reasoning traces.
Synthesizing data for some arbitrary thing ... I'm not sure that would be the same thing.
It's hard to draw the line.
But the Chinese models are absolutely distilling - and would not be competitive without this distillation.
At the same time, there's a lot of real innovation and regular building going on at the same time over there.