logoalt Hacker News

spaceman_2020yesterday at 5:27 AM14 repliesview on HN

All my adult life, China has given me cheap material goods. Whatever they do in their country is their own problem. They’ve never interfered in my politics or started any wars


Replies

vlovich123yesterday at 5:44 AM

> They’ve never interfered in my politics or started any wars

But they have. I dont know what specific country you are referring to but China has interfered with US elections as well as Canada, Taiwan, and Australia in addition to many many others.

They’ve annexed Tibet (1950), fought India (1962) and Vietnam (1979) among others and more recently in 2020 a deadly skirmish with India. They’ve generally shifted their focus to cyber military actions but you’d have to be pretty naive they won’t start to exercise military control over Taiwan when/if they get a chance.

show 16 replies
KronisLVyesterday at 6:41 AM

> Whatever they do in their country is their own problem.

Idk to me it feels like human compassion and ethics dictates that you at least have to care a bit even about the things in other countries. Otherwise all sorts of horrible domestic policies would be justifiable.

show 1 reply
Sohcahtoa82yesterday at 4:48 PM

I wish I could be this blissfully naive.

China is becoming an intellectual powerhouse in addition to a manufacturing powerhouse and runs huge spyware and propaganda campaigns.

Read up about T95, MBOX, TVBOX, or other Android TV Boxes advertised as generic TV streaming devices advertised as "unlocked" or capable of accessing free content. They're loaded with spyware/malware, typically BADBOX. Some of them will record audio and record your network traffic and send it to China.

I'm also convinced that the anti-education thread winding its way through US culture is being amplified by China. They likely didn't start it, as it's been growing for decades, but China will happily keep it going.

theplumberyesterday at 8:03 AM

That's a very selfish way to think of it. Whatever they do in their country does not stay in their country because China is becoming a superpower so you should expect it (as it's normal) to interfere and affect policy abroad.

For example Lithuania has been punished for letting Taiwan opening an embassy (in Lithuania). So China cares what other countries do in their country. Without EU support Lithuania could have faced very harsh consequences. That's just an example. Another example is the "secret police" stations undeclared overseas police stations operated by China in various countries (i.e. U.S for example). China gave you cheap material goods because that was its business but you have to keep in mind it's an authoritarian, communist regime. It carries an extra risk on top of the potential economic coercion if you give it too power. At least you know that U.S is only after the money and does not want to turn your country in a communist "utopia".

That being said this does not mean we should ban Chinese AI models because China didn't cross any red lines(yet) compared with Russia for example.

show 1 reply
PatronBernardyesterday at 7:39 AM

For you personally no, but there's plenty of scandals of politicians being influenced by the Chinese, case in point in my own country: https://www.ft.com/content/601df41f-8393-46ad-9f74-fe64f8ea1...

Don't be naive or I might even think you're working for the Chinese :-)

blackhazyesterday at 6:36 AM

But they're happily selling drone parts to Russians dropping bombs on civilians (or "whatever").

show 3 replies
sailfastyesterday at 2:07 PM

What country do you live in? Nevermind it doesn’t matter because literally every country has had their politics interfered with.

john-h-kyesterday at 4:59 PM

I personally think it’s bad when countries commit genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Uyghurs_in_Chin...

b3lvedereyesterday at 6:28 AM

Oh i bet they have not directly interfered with your politics, but they do interfer a lots in various things. More than any other country on this planet? I don't know. China is big. Really really big.

t0bia_syesterday at 6:27 AM

Do you remember covid and where it come from?

show 2 replies
altmanaltmanyesterday at 5:49 AM

I mean them selling the cheap material goods is politics, and they use that a lot to threaten other countries. They constantly bully neighbors and assert claims on foreign terriroty. They might not be the comic book villians people are making them out to be but your take is just ignorant

show 1 reply
cechmasteryesterday at 7:43 AM

They have their own genocide in western china

show 1 reply
preisschildyesterday at 7:35 AM

> They’ve never interfered in my politics or started any wars

They actively back russia and deliver them weapons and support them with their attempted Genocide in Ukraine. They also actively threaten Taiwan.

Not to mention them claiming almost the entire South China Sea even though this being against international law and threatening smaller nations into submitting to them