logoalt Hacker News

gowldyesterday at 4:56 PM2 repliesview on HN

What you are doing is "motte and bailey".

The motte is "AI useful". The bailey is "Singularity is nigh".


Replies

Windchaseryesterday at 5:23 PM

The unified position which many folks deny is "AI is powerful" or, alternatively, "AI will be powerful soon".

(I'm personally still skeptical about this, but I'm being pulled towards accepting it).

"AI is useful" is too low of a bar, and "singularity is nigh" is too high. "AI is on its way to upending society" is about in the middle, and still vastly contentious among laypeople.

enraged_camelyesterday at 5:22 PM

>> The motte is "AI useful". The bailey is "Singularity is nigh".

But there are people like Ed Zitron, frequently posted and cited here, who disagree even with the former.

show 2 replies