logoalt Hacker News

That Disgraceful, Disreputable, (Wonderful) Form of Punctuation: The Parenthesis

35 pointsby pseudolustoday at 1:22 AM19 commentsview on HN

Comments

radarsat1today at 5:48 AM

I used to use them very frequently. It took noticing that I was parenthesizing the second half of almost every sentence I wrote (to add a bit more info, like this), to make me go back and evaluate if I could remove them and replace with commas, or just break the sentence. I found that it was possible on almost all cases. Since then, I started doing this automatically as I started writing a "(" and then I kind of naturally stopped using parentheses so much. It was a bad habit that I somehow formed and found a means to self-correct.

stillpointlabtoday at 5:48 AM

One of my pet peeves is people opening a parenthesis and never closing it. It's like my brain pushes the parenthetical into a stack and when I get to the end of the paragraph it throws an error.

I definitely overuse parenthesis and I haven't found a way to rid myself of the habit (as I managed to mostly rid myself of the habit of using semi-colons).

show 1 reply
juriptoday at 5:30 AM

The one place where I find parenthesis really jarring is in the middle of quotes. I just can't wrap my head around something like

> "I'm sending (via email) an encrypted message", Alice said to Bob

Especially in a book that's been supposedly copy edited. Em dashes or commas or just a plain run-on sentences feel much more appropriate for the general lack of structure in real speech.

oskatoday at 3:08 AM

I don't like the two examples of parenthesis used in the title & subtitle of this piece, where they put wonderful and perfect in parentheses before a noun phrase.

Putting adjectives in parentheses before a noun (phrase) is, yes, a useful device but those adjectives should usually be words that give more (but not necessary) information, rather than purely subjective qualifiers such as the two that the author uses. I know they're probably being a bit tongue in cheek but it still grates a little that these were the two examples they led with.

show 1 reply
sudo_cowsaytoday at 2:50 AM

I don't know why but I seem to use more parenthesis (even if I should be using commas).

show 1 reply
xebulontoday at 5:54 AM

"He was certainly a flamboyantly creative writer and inspired teacher; yet one can take him seriously here: “Pricks” performed “tricks” as punctuation became a vehicle to think about the technological revolutions of the time, gender relationships, and literary genres reflecting social and historical concerns like kingship or geographical exploration."

absolute trainwreck.

pluctoday at 6:06 AM

No Amount of Grammatical Feats Will Make You Look Smart If You Use Word Capitalization.

gololtoday at 5:08 AM

I just had thw thought: aren't parentheses just punctuation denoting an inline footnote?

show 1 reply
dtnmtoday at 6:44 AM

You can't escape them.

jibaltoday at 7:16 AM

Five comments here write "parenthesis" where they mean "parentheses" ... weird.

pfdietztoday at 4:06 AM

And not a single mention of Lisp? Tsk.

6LLvveMx2koXfwntoday at 5:09 AM

Came for comments with an unreasonable amount of parenthesis; not disappointed.

pseingatltoday at 5:43 AM

Now having a revival because AI killed the em dash.