logoalt Hacker News

asdfsa32today at 3:52 AM9 repliesview on HN

For Linux, there is https://github.com/pwr-Solaar/Solaar

But on another note, the genai content on the website is just so distracting and such a bummer. It sticks out like sore thumb.


Replies

thihttoday at 7:58 AM

> the genai content on the website is just so distracting and such a bummer

That's harsh. Consider English might not be the author's first language (I see Chinese on the screenshots). Just opening the site I get all the info I need from the text (local first, no account, no telemetry, that's great), install instructions are immediately visible, there are screenshots, even the config file format is one scroll away. This is a great landing page for an open source tool.

show 3 replies
wateralientoday at 11:03 AM

Before AI you'd be saying it's a great website for a free and open source app.

aetherspawntoday at 6:29 AM

This website still would have taken at least a week to make. It’s pretty nice for an open source project website.

Between no website and shiny but crappy LLM website, I’ll take the latter, and I wouldn’t wish another 2 weeks of unpaid copy writing on any open source dev.

show 3 replies
_345today at 4:36 AM

Yeah even if the software is good there's just something sad about realizing you're reading AI generated text. Even if its proofread and factually correct it just comes across as cheap and low effort, moreso when the content gets duplicated in a pointless FAQ that just restates everything you just read

show 3 replies
bjackmantoday at 10:07 AM

Nothing wrong with the AI website but it suggests the code is AI too.

Nothing wrong with AI code either but it suggests the project may have been built in 2 weeks, has no community and low likelihood of ongoing maintenance.

So now overall instead of a flashy website I think the best signal of quality is a boring GitHub README and several months of commit activity, lots of merged PRs.

show 2 replies
maybewhenthesuntoday at 7:38 AM

I reads like a corporate driver page. I'd much prefer a simple git repo with a readme.md

show 1 reply
vccvxvccvvxctoday at 10:11 AM

A "nice site" was a proxy metric for "thoughtful competence". It was always flawed, but LLMs put the final nail in that particular coffin.

bellard.org style text-only, get-to-the-point-please content will the way forwards. "browsers" can then style and rewrite it till the cows come home - with fancy slideshows, LLMisms, carrousels, the works - or not and nobody will be worse off.

The way we structure content these days is insane. Separate content from presentation, please.

erichdongublertoday at 8:27 AM

It seems the project is actually aware of this:

> Quit Logi Options+ before launching: the two fight over HID++ access, and only one app can own a receiver at a time. On Linux, the same applies to Solaar.

WD-42today at 4:16 AM

Solaar is fantastic software. Not worth replacing with slop even if the slop looks shiny.

show 1 reply