logoalt Hacker News

insane_dreamertoday at 4:17 PM2 repliesview on HN

right, there's a contradiction here:

- if you're deemed to be on US soil, constitutional protections (4A) apply; can't be destroying "evidence" unless you're accused of a crime or found to have committed a crime

- if you're deemed _not_ yet on US soil, then how can you be charged with a crime under _US_ law?


Replies

freeone3000today at 7:25 PM

The US views that US law applies worldwide. There is no requirement that you be anywhere near the US to be under US jurisdiction for an alleged offense against the US, according to the US.

Also, that constitutional protections are suspended within 100 miles of a land, sea, or air border.

show 2 replies
groby_btoday at 8:28 PM

4A still doesn't permit you to destroy the evidence. Resist on 4A grounds, destroy the evidence, 4A reasons get overturned - you've got yourself a conviction. US v. Akram Musleh.

show 1 reply