logoalt Hacker News

dekhn • yesterday at 4:15 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

This is fairly typical for genetic studies. We can observe an association, without understanding the causal relationship. Those of us who take the molecular biology/biophysical view of genes and proteins have been watching the geneticists slowly discover that "the allele of a gene that codes for" mental model is very limited; at least they're starting to pay more attention to the regulatory changes and indels and structural rearrangements, even if they don't have the tools to explain the underlying mechanism.

Like most hair/skin coloring, it's related to melanin production, regulation, and distribution.


Replies

roughly • yesterday at 6:22 PM

Very often the appropriate lens for genetic expression isn’t traits, it’s tools - a gene knockout isn’t “blue eyes now”, it’s “socket #6 is missing from the kit,” which is why you’ll see blue eyes and a bunch of other unrelated stuff.

(With love to my blue-eyed friends in the thread)

➕ show 1 reply
bbor • yesterday at 7:32 PM

Yeah but there's good reason for an investigation here, in particular:

  Arhgap36 is known to cause developmental problems in other animals when it is over- or under-functioning.
➕ show 1 reply