alt Hacker NewsHelp me understand. When you write a post about designing a system, do you not do some basic diligence about what existing systems you resemble?
Open source is not IP maximalist by any means. I am merely asking that the appropriate credit be provided.
Replies
zamalek • today at 10:50 PM
What happened is that it wasn't a FAANG engineer replicating what they know, rather one asked Claude what to do and it told them to replicate what it knew.
That's how the knowledge that it was a facsimile was lost.
kccqzy • today at 9:58 PM
Absolutely not. When I create projects I only credit other existing systems if they are a direct inspiration. If I independently come up with the same idea as someone else I see no reason for me to do the due diligence and credit them.
➕ show 1 reply
No. I actually don’t do that and I don’t think that all human work should be O(n) deduplication gated.
Written about it here before: https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/Blog/2026-09-08/Intellectual...
It isn’t something I care very much about, except when it’s used as a certificate of achievement. I almost never do literature searches with an attempt to dedupe. I only ever do it to see if someone has explored something better than I have. That’s often the case but other times it is not.