logoalt Hacker News

JumpCrisscross • yesterday at 9:11 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> ethnically cleansed Palestinians aren't even allowed to live on their land, let alone vote

America was a democracy while we were exterminating our native population. Democracy is a system of government. Voters can democratically vote for terrible things.

Israeli Arabs are allowed to vote.

> Israel is an apartheid state

This is a valid argument, though still stretched–America didn't cease to be a democracy while we occupied Germany and Japan.


Replies

slowin • yesterday at 9:21 PM

Murdered people can't vote. People forced off their land and over an artificially created border can't vote. Israel is no democracy.

> America was a democracy while we were exterminating our native population.

I would argue that it was not for the very same reasons (and of course there were many other classes not allowed to vote at the time). Killing someone robs them of their right to vote.

➕ show 1 reply