logoalt Hacker News

IPv6 delegation, an unusually subtle failure mode

58 points • by genghizkhan • last Sunday at 6:06 PM • 39 comments • view on HN

Comments

arcfour • today at 1:44 PM

Why do you even need networkd for a router? Setting one up on Alpine (so not all this cruft) is easy as pie and the whole thing can cold boot in under 10 seconds... Would make the whole setup much more understandable + smaller attack surface...

> I usually prefer using systemd utilities wherever possible.

Ah. There's your problem. When something promises it can do anything and everything, rarely can it do much of it well, I find...

The type of issue you encountered is a pervasive failure mode you will encounter the more and more systemd utilities you rely on. For something like a router, systemd is wholly unnecessary. Try it! You'll agree.

➕ show 3 replies
RVuRnvbM2e • today at 1:31 PM

Isn't it a misconfiguration that the ISP is handing out a different prefix each time pppd restarts? Shouldn't the prefix be fairly static?

➕ show 2 replies
wowczarek • today at 2:53 PM

I thought PD in Linux and *BSDs was a solved issue. I think I've been spoilt by dedicated NOSes.

➕ show 1 reply
miyuru • today at 3:19 PM

One my LTE router's had a similar issue, which i documented for anyone(or AI agents) stumbling on it here.

https://blog.miyuru.lk/zlt-ipv6-fixes/

o_-_o • today at 1:27 PM

I think the most disturbing part of this article is; "I haven't replaced the dead CMOS battery on my router and the clock resets every time the router restarts." O_o

➕ show 2 replies
jon128 • today at 2:23 PM

Part of how some of my devices cope with ISPs doing things the wrong way is to ping IP addresses belonging to nearby AS and some remote AS from the source addresses of each local IP prefix.

When a local IP prefix is detected as stale relative to other local IP prefixes, my local router(s) sound out appropriate router announcements to squash the stale prefixes.

Devices I travel with do the same.

It seems these days, most eyeball networks aren't too technical, rely on whatever closed source software vendors poop out, and for the most part they are just plugging things in. That, and billing.

arbor-group • today at 2:59 PM

[flagged]

Spalau • today at 2:02 PM

[dead]