logoalt Hacker News

tsimionescu • yesterday at 9:43 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

But still - the basic space-time group properties and symmetries don't give you the actual particles, not even a little bit. You could maybe say they give you a concept of a particle, and you can describe the actual particles that happen to exist in our universe using the properties that this group defines - sure. But you can't simply write the group symmetries and discover that a particle with spin 1/2 and mass 0.15MeV has to exist - you just discover that particles in this theory are described by mass and spin, with a certain relation between possible combinations of mass and spin. But there's still an infinite number of such possible combinations, and only 30 or so actual elementary particles.

Plus, calling the particles that you get out of such a theory "the electron" or "the quark" is profoundly misleading. If you only start with a space-time related symmetry, you don't get "electrons", you maybe get particles with the spin and mass of an electron. But it doesn't have charge, nor color nor weak hypercharge. It doesn't decay and doesn't absorb photons nor do anything else that an electron does - it's not an electron. You need to combine this with a lot more symmetry groups to start getting the actual particles, and even then you still need to add the experimentally discovered values to match physics - the math allows for infinite numbers of various particles with properties similar to the ones our universe actually contains.

I'd also note that apparently the Euclidean group doesn't have anything to do with particles anyway, it's the Poincarre group whose irreducible symmetries lead to the (mass, spin) description of particles.


Replies

programjames • yesterday at 10:22 PM

The Euclidean group is a Wick rotation off from the Poincaire group. I think it is valid to call these particles. You can tack on the gauge group later to get your 'qualia'.

➕ show 1 reply