logoalt Hacker News

loeg • yesterday at 10:06 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Why? There aren't very many obstacles at altitude. Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground. (Obviously, airplanes go even faster, but similarly benefit from a lack of obstacles.)


Replies

doodlebugging • today at 12:11 AM

I guess you may not have spent much time watching birds or other wild animals navigate their environments. Many birds routinely fly at maximum speed through trees, dodging branches, leaves, and twigs that would knock them off course and lighting suddenly on small limbs or branches that you can't even see until you are deep into the foliage. Maybe they can see them from outside the leaf envelope. It would explain how they are able to navigate such a cluttered environment in shadow at full speed. Birds may crash into window glass regularly but their innate understanding of navigation around and through natural obstacles is pretty remarkable.

Watching drone racing videos gives an idea of just how complicated the task turns out to be - flitting through narrow openings at speed and zipping around obstacles that suddenly appear. Birds were doing this millenia before anyone programmed a drone.

jyounker • yesterday at 11:16 PM

> Why? There aren't very many obstacles at altitude.

Most birds don't spend their time flying at high altitudes. Most of the time they're remarkably close to the ground, and there are lots of obstacles when you're close to he ground. Some of those are trying to avoid being eaten, and others are looking for dinner.

> Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground.

That's just within the last 150 years, and has no relevance for our evolutionary history.

asdff • today at 12:24 AM

Humans actually change the environment to meet their sensory slowdowns at that sort of speed. E.g. spacing of road signs and even their size depends on the speed of the road, in anticipation of you needing more distance to make decisions at this speed, given your thinking speed didn't change.

A hummingbird on the other hand is moving with precision at its top speed in the environment as it is. It is adapted to this behavior at these speeds and maneuverability, while our lack of adaption needs that sort of sensory crutch.

whatever1 • yesterday at 10:31 PM

Humans going fast is a thing that happened just yesterday (from evolutionary perspective).